100% free reservations. Only for Canadian restaurants. Switching? Free migration.
Restaurant tech

Square Loyalty vs TouchBistro Loyalty in Canada

By Pete RossNovember 17, 20268 min read
A server bringing the bill to a regular guest at a small restaurant table

Square Loyalty and TouchBistro Loyalty aren't really rivals. Each one runs only on its own company's POS, so the system on your counter has already made the choice for you. What's left to compare is what each costs on top of that POS, what your guests actually see, and what happens to your members if you ever leave. On those three, Square is the open book and TouchBistro is the quote.

One more thing up front, because nobody else mentions it: if your restaurant is in Quebec, neither one is on the table. More on that below.

What do Square Loyalty and TouchBistro Loyalty cost on top of the POS?

Here's what each company publishes on its Canadian-facing pages, checked on November 17, 2026. All prices are before tax.

Square Loyalty TouchBistro Loyalty
POS it needs Square for Restaurants: Free ($0) or Plus ($60/month) TouchBistro POS: from $89/month, or $99/month for the Essentials bundle (currency not named)
Loyalty price $60/month per location up to 500 loyalty visits, $100 up to 1,500, $140 above Quote only. Review sites report a former list price of US$99/month
What's metered Loyalty visits: every enrolment, point earned or reward redeemed Set in your quote
Contract None. Month to month Set in your quote
Trial or promo 30 days free "3 months free" promo, terms not shown on the page
Email and text campaigns Square Marketing, from $20/month TouchBistro Marketing, quote only
Available in Quebec No (Square POS isn't compatible with WEB-SRM) No ("excluding Québec")

Sources: Square Loyalty pricing, Square for Restaurants pricing, Square Canada pricing, TouchBistro pricing, TouchBistro Loyalty.

Run it for a 40-seat room on Square Plus. POS and Loyalty together come to $120 a month, or $1,440 a year, before card processing. If the program works and you cross 500 loyalty visits, Loyalty steps to $100 and the pair costs $1,920 a year. That's the strange part of Square's model: the bill goes up exactly when the program does its job. Our guide to what loyalty software costs in Canada walks through how to estimate your tier from your cover counts.

On TouchBistro, the same room starts at $89 for the POS plus whatever the loyalty quote says. If it lands near that old US$99 figure, that's roughly $140 a month in Canadian dollars at recent exchange rates, so around $2,750 a year for the two. That's our estimate, not TouchBistro's number. Ask for the quote in Canadian dollars, in writing, before the demo ends.

One owner on r/restaurantowners described the creep on Square this way: "suddenly Square had tons of fees for everything." It's a fair warning for both systems. Loyalty is rarely the add-on that hurts on its own. It's the fourth or fifth one.

Reservation software. Free for Canadian restaurants. $0 a month

Set up your restaurant

What does a guest actually see?

This is where the two products feel different.

Square Loyalty is built around a phone number. After paying, the guest types their mobile number on the screen, and that's the sign-up. Square's Canadian help pages say guests can also enrol on an invoice or online when they complete a purchase, then track their points and rewards. You can reward visits, spend, specific items or a category, and the reward can be a discount on the bill, a free item or a combo. The guest needs a mobile number, and that's about all.

TouchBistro Loyalty earns points automatically through the POS, based on spend and items ordered. Guests check their balance in a branded Customer Web App, which works in a phone browser with no download, or ask staff at the table. They can also earn and redeem on online orders if you run TouchBistro's online ordering. One limit worth knowing: a guest can't load a dollar value onto a loyalty account. Stored value lives in TouchBistro's separate Gift Cards product, which is another quote.

Our take: Square's sign-up is the lighter of the two. A phone number at the end of the bill asks almost nothing of a guest. TouchBistro's web app earns its place if you already sell online orders through TouchBistro, because the same guest earns in the room and from the couch.

Neither one asks a guest to download an app, and that's the right call for a single room. Nobody wants a 23rd loyalty app for one bistro.

What happens to your members if you change POS?

This is the question the sales demo skips, and it's the one that matters most over five years.

On Square, your customer directory can be exported with contact details. Loyalty balances are another story. Square staff in its seller community have said for years that there's no self-serve export of loyalty points; you call support and they email a file of phone numbers and points. Operators in the same thread report that file came without names. Those are older forum answers, so ask Square what's current before you rely on it. If you cancel Loyalty but stay on Square, staff replies say the points stay on file, but guests can't earn or enrol while it's off.

On TouchBistro, we couldn't find public documentation on exporting loyalty members or balances at all. That doesn't mean it's impossible. It means it's a question to put in writing before you sign. TouchBistro also changed hands this year: Harris, part of Constellation Software, bought it in July 2026. A new owner doesn't change your program overnight, but it can change pricing at your next renewal.

The pattern is the same on both sides. POS-tied loyalty keeps your members inside the POS company's system. That's convenient right up until you want to leave, and independents do change POS, often every few years. When you do, 300 guests are halfway to a free dessert, and you have to decide how to honour those balances. Ontario and Quebec both have rules on when points can expire, which we cover in the loyalty software cost guide.

So ask both vendors the same four questions:

  1. Can I export members, phone numbers, emails and point balances myself, as a spreadsheet?
  2. Does that export include names?
  3. If I cancel loyalty but keep the POS, what do guests see?
  4. If I leave the POS, how long do I have to pull the data?

What if your restaurant is in Quebec?

Then this comparison is short. Square says its products "are not compatible" with WEB-SRM, Quebec's mandatory billing system for restaurants, so Square for Restaurants isn't a legal setup for most Quebec dining rooms. And TouchBistro's loyalty page says plainly that the product is available in Canada "excluding Québec."

That leaves two paths. Use the loyalty tool that comes with a POS certified by Revenu Québec, or run a wallet stamp card beside whatever certified system you have. Our guide to the cheapest POS for a small restaurant covers the certified shortlist.

Which one should you pick?

The one that matches your POS, and only if the numbers hold up. Never switch POS to get a loyalty program. A POS decision is about service, card rates and contract terms, which we compared in Toast vs TouchBistro. Loyalty is a small line item riding on top of it.

Your situation What to do
On Square, outside Quebec Square Loyalty. Estimate your loyalty visits first, and ask support for a points export once a year so you always hold a copy
On TouchBistro, outside Quebec Get the loyalty quote in Canadian dollars, with the term. If it runs past $100 a month, price it against a wallet stamp card
Already selling online orders through TouchBistro TouchBistro Loyalty makes more sense, since guests earn in the room and online in one place
In Quebec Neither. Look at the loyalty tool on your certified POS, or a stamp card beside it
Not sure guests want a program at all Start with paper for three months

Before you sign anything, run the break-even. The software is rarely the expensive part: the rewards are. Our math on whether loyalty programs are worth it shows a 40-seat room where a $20-off reward costs five times more than a free dessert, whichever software counts the stamps.

And keep the software in proportion. An owner on r/restaurantowners put it well last month: "The regulars are already receiving 'rewards' for coming often - special treatment, favorite seats, remembered orders, etc." A loyalty program can count visits. Your team is the one who remembers the order.

When you're ready to take reservations, Trudy's Table is built for Canadian independents. Canadian owned, and every booking adds to a guest history your whole team can see, whichever POS sits on the counter.


Sources: Square Loyalty pricing, Canada, Square for Restaurants pricing, Canada, Square Canada pricing, Square Loyalty overview, Square Seller Community on loyalty exports, Square Seller Community on cancelling Loyalty, TouchBistro Loyalty, TouchBistro pricing, Harris.


Frequently Asked Questions

Is Square Loyalty or TouchBistro Loyalty cheaper in Canada?

Square publishes its price: $60 a month per location for up to 500 loyalty visits, then $100 and $140, with no contract and a 30-day trial. TouchBistro Loyalty is quote-only; review sites report a former list price of US$99 a month. Each also needs its own POS, so compare the POS and loyalty together, in Canadian dollars.

Is the Square loyalty program worth it?

It can be for a single room already on Square, as long as you estimate your loyalty visits first. Every enrolment, point earned and reward redeemed counts, so a busy program moves from $60 to $100 a month. The rewards you hand out usually cost more than the software, so run the break-even before you start.

Can I use Square Loyalty or TouchBistro Loyalty with another POS?

No. Square Loyalty runs on Square's POS and TouchBistro Loyalty runs on TouchBistro's POS. If you want a program that works beside any POS, look at a wallet stamp card or a standalone loyalty platform instead. Never switch POS just to get a loyalty program.

What happens to loyalty points if I switch POS?

They stay in the old vendor's system. Square lets you export customer contact details, but loyalty points have to be requested from support, and operators report the file comes without names. TouchBistro doesn't publish export steps. Ask both vendors, in writing, how you'd take members and balances with you.

Can Quebec restaurants use Square Loyalty or TouchBistro Loyalty?

No. Square says its products are not compatible with WEB-SRM, Quebec's mandatory billing system for restaurants, and TouchBistro Loyalty is available in Canada excluding Québec. A Quebec restaurant should look at the loyalty tool on a POS certified by Revenu Québec, or a stamp card beside it.

Tags
loyalty softwareSquare LoyaltyTouchBistro LoyaltyPOS systemsrestaurant technologyCanadian restaurantsindependent restaurantsguest data
Back to blog

Continue reading

A card terminal on a small café counter beside a folded apron and a paper receipt
Restaurant tech

Cheapest POS for a Small Restaurant in Canada: Real Costs

The cheapest POS for a small Canadian restaurant depends on your average ticket, not the software price. A counter doing $20,000 a month pays about $5,800 in year one on Square's Free plan. A 28-seat room pays roughly $8,800 to $10,900, and card processing is the biggest line either way. In Quebec, neither Square nor Moneris Go Restaurant is an option.

November 3, 2026

Three takeout bags with name stickers lined up on a restaurant pickup shelf
Restaurant tech

Takeout POS Systems in Canada: What They Do and Cost

A takeout and delivery POS has to do four things a dine-in POS doesn't: pull orders from your website and the delivery apps into one queue, pace the kitchen when orders pile up, change the menu everywhere at once, and process online payments. In Canada, software runs from $0 to a few hundred dollars a month. Card processing and app commissions are the bigger costs.

October 16, 2026

Two different restaurant POS tablets side by side on a server station before service
Restaurant tech

Toast vs TouchBistro: Pricing, Reporting and Fit in Canada

For a single-location, full-service independent in Canada, TouchBistro is the easier fit: it runs on iPads, was built around table service, and is based in Toronto. Toast goes deeper on reporting and back-office tools but needs its own hardware and usually a two-to-three-year term. Software list prices are close. Processing rates, hardware and contract length decide the real bill.

October 15, 2026

A small Toronto restaurant before service, a tablet POS resting on the bar beside cheque presenters
Restaurant tech

Restaurant POS Systems in Toronto: What Independents Pay

Toronto independents mostly choose between Square, TouchBistro, Lightspeed, Toast, Clover and Moneris. Ontario's single 13% HST means any of them handles tax, so the decision comes down to card processing, contract terms and support. On $24,000 a month in credit sales, processing costs about ten times the software fee. Two Toronto-based players also changed owners in 2026.

September 30, 2026

Restaurant host stand with a single tablet, quiet afternoon light
Restaurant tech

Restaurant Tech Trends 2026: Less Is the Move

The biggest restaurant tech trend for 2026 isn't a new tool. It's using fewer of them. Research from the James Beard Foundation and TouchBistro shows that operators with moderate, intentional tech adoption outperform those at both extremes. While the industry chases robot servers and AI phone bots, the real gains for independents come from consolidation, quiet automation, and keeping control of your customer data.

July 29, 2026

Reservation software.
Free for Canadian restaurants.

$0a month

  • Booking widget
  • Guest history
  • Table management
  • SMS reminders
  • Card-on-file
  • Free setup
Set up your restaurant

Canadian ownedSupport from a real person, in French or English