Enter your items, get a Stars/Plowhorses/Puzzles/Dogs classification with a visual matrix and clear next steps.
| Item name | Price | Food cost | Qty sold | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ | |||
$ | $ |
Your menu matrix
8
Items analyzed
$14.34
Avg. contribution margin
31.4%
Avg. food cost
$28,855
Total revenue
High profit, high popularity. Your best performers.
Protect these items. Keep them prominent on the menu, maintain quality and portion size, and resist the urge to change what works.
Low profit, high popularity. Guests love them, but margins are thin.
Reduce food cost through portion control, supplier negotiation, or ingredient substitution. Test small price increases. Pair with high-margin sides or add-ons.
High profit, low popularity. Great margins, but not enough guests order them.
Boost visibility: move them to a high-attention spot on the menu, train servers to recommend them, or rename for more appeal. If nothing works, consider replacing.
Low profit, low popularity. Neither profitable nor popular.
Remove from the menu unless they serve a specific purpose (kids menu, dietary option). Fewer items means less waste and simpler operations.
The framework
Menu engineering is a method for analyzing each dish by two dimensions: how profitable it is (contribution margin) and how popular it is (sales mix). The result is a 2x2 matrix that classifies every item into one of four categories.
Each item's share of total orders. If you sell 1,000 items and one dish accounts for 150 of them, its menu mix is 15%. An item is "popular" if its mix exceeds the popularity threshold (see below).
Selling price minus food cost. A $24 dish with $8 in food cost has a $16 contribution margin. An item is "profitable" if its CM exceeds the weighted average across all items.
The popularity cutoff is (1 / number of items) x 70%. With 10 items, the threshold is 7%. This accounts for the fact that not all items sell equally, and is the industry standard used in hospitality programs worldwide.
Take action
These are your money makers. Give them prime placement on the menu, maintain consistent quality, and avoid unnecessary changes. If it works, leave it alone.
Guests order these, so the demand is there. Your job is to make them more profitable. Negotiate with suppliers, adjust portions, test a small price bump, or pair them with high-margin sides.
The margins are good but guests overlook them. Rename them, move them to the top-right of the menu (where eyes go first), add a "chef's pick" badge, or have servers recommend them.
Low margin, low demand. Unless there's a strategic reason to keep them (allergen-friendly option, kids menu staple), remove them. A shorter menu means less waste, faster prep, and a clearer story for guests.
Go deeper
How to run a full menu engineering analysis, step by step. From pulling your POS data to making changes that stick.
Read articleA typical 40-seat Canadian restaurant could recover $50K-$75K/year by tackling food waste, no-shows, and menu mispricing.
Read articleRestaurants across Canada are joining
Reservations, table management, guest history, and card-on-file for $299. Once. No subscription. First 50 restaurants only.
We’ll only text you to verify your number and let you know when we launch so you can claim your lifetime access.
Built in Quebec · No credit card · No spam
FAQ
Menu engineering is a framework for classifying menu items by profitability (contribution margin) and popularity (sales mix). Each item falls into one of four categories: Stars (high profit, high popularity), Plowhorses (low profit, high popularity), Puzzles (high profit, low popularity), or Dogs (low profit, low popularity).
Each item’s contribution margin (selling price minus food cost) is compared against the weighted average CM across all items. Its sales mix (share of total orders) is compared against the 70% popularity threshold. Items above both benchmarks are Stars. Below both are Dogs. The other two combinations give you Plowhorses and Puzzles.
The threshold is calculated as (1 / number of items) x 70%. With 10 menu items, the cutoff is 7% of total sales. This is the standard method used in hospitality management programs and accounts for the fact that sales are never evenly distributed.
Not necessarily. Some Dogs serve a purpose: a kids menu item, an allergen-friendly option, or a dish that completes a section. But if a Dog has no strategic reason to exist, removing it simplifies your kitchen, reduces waste, and lets you focus on items that perform.
Lifetime access to Trudy’s Table: reservations, table management, guest history, card-on-file, automated reminders, perks, and add-ons. No monthly fees.
No. You’re reserving your spot on the list. When Trudy’s Table launches, we’ll text you with instructions to activate your lifetime access for $299.
Your menu has answers. Read them.
Claim your spot